Pseudomé Studio Projects Forum Index Pseudomé Studio Projects

 
 FAQFAQ   SearchSearch   MemberlistMemberlist   UsergroupsUsergroups   RegisterRegister 
 ProfileProfile   Log in to check your private messagesLog in to check your private messages   Log inLog in 

My GOD, here comes Disney.
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3
 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Pseudomé Studio Projects Forum Index -> TOKYOPOP And The Manga Industry
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Physalis
Power Level: Frieza


Joined: 17 Nov 2003
Posts: 1173
Location: Atop Mt. KK

PostPosted: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:51 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

I was about to say the her art is a uh,....joke.

But then again, I don't have a deal with Disney...

Hope it works out.
_________________
"Many attempt to harvest what was never planted"
====================================
Leading the Anti-Kooky Korner movement since yesterday
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Rivkah
Power Level: Ginyu


Joined: 17 Oct 2003
Posts: 962
Location: Austin, TX

PostPosted: Sun Oct 31, 2004 11:58 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Rikki: Eep! I meant Bookscan. Here's an article with a link to the last week of 2003 numbers: http://www.newsarama.com/pages/Tilting/TatWv2_2a.htm If you'd like to actually order current information from Bookscan, here's their website: http://www.bookscan.com/contact.html

There's also always Bowker, but unless you have $9,000 lying around, you might want to overlook this link: http://www.simbanet.com/

Queenie: Smile There's a reason my friends call me the Google Queen. ^_~ I'm a numbers hog and an information junkie.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
crispy
Power Level: King Cold


Joined: 18 Jun 2004
Posts: 1479

PostPosted: Sun Oct 31, 2004 12:19 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

lol, all you artist people know eachother and work in cohoots with insiders at TP... the only people I get close to from TP are people I used to work in scanlations with... how sad...

[quote IronMouse] To Rikki and Tavisha: Since you two are here and you've been drawing manga for 10 years, do you think you can give some of us on this board some pointers on how you promoted yourselves? Someone who's been around for 10 years will certainly have quality info to add. Your advice would be much appreciated. smile.gif [/quote]

I totally agree. It'd be interesting to hear how to market yourself. Marty's little Story Bible thing was interesting, but maybe there's more to it?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
RikkiSimons
Power Level: Dodoria


Joined: 16 Jul 2004
Posts: 68

PostPosted: Mon Nov 01, 2004 1:48 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

IronMouse wrote:
To Rikki and Tavisha: Since you two are here and you've been drawing manga for 10 years, do you think you can give some of us on this board some pointers on how you promoted yourselves? Someone who's been around for 10 years will certainly have quality info to add. Your advice would be much appreciated.


I can point you to our FAQ, here: http://www.tavicat.com/faq.html but it mostly relates to our time involved with the direct comic market. What you guys are facing today is a completely new world for comics, especially manga influenced comics. Because of Tokyopop and other factors, the comic industry has been forced to grow out of the secluded direct market, which focused entirely on selling to comic shops, and into the regular book market which focuses on sales to the wider book store market. As Tom Spurgeon of the Comics Reporter points out here: http://www.comicsreporter.com/index.php/public_service_announcement/ , this is a time of alarming publishing deals.

For more than two decades comics creators have been faced with two publishing models, 1. publish a flimsy 24 page super hero story with Marvel or DC and get an advance based on a page rate, or 2. publish a flimsy 24 page alternative comic with a small indie publisher with little or no advance up front. With either model you sell only to the direct market (comic shops), where comic shop owners buy comics that are unreturnable to the publisher, and your earnings as a comics creator is based on your nearly instant sales to comic shops, not customers. If customers don't buy your comics, the shops that ordered them are stuck with them. Yet, now with the near destruction of the direct market, publisher's are forced to follow the model of the regular book industry, where advances are given to the author of a work that must reflect a wage sustainable to create a 150+ page volume, and books are sold to regular book stores, where money paid to the publisher actually reflects customer purchases and books that go unsold to customers are returnable to the publisher at the publisher's expense. This is a far more expensive world than the direct market

Honestly, I never intended to make comics. I was attempting prose novels in the early 1990's and Tavisha and I intended to get into the young adult fiction market. Because we loved anime and manga, we got diverted into making comics after meeting Mark Paniccia at Anime Con in 1993. I like comics, but I love books and the book format, whether that format contains prose or comics. I've never been fond of the direct market. One of the most aggravating things I used to hear in the direct market was a retailer telling a customer that our comic was sold out. This meant that either 1. the retailer was lying and didn’t order any at all, or 2. the retailer ordered one copy and didn’t plan on ordering any more. This sort of thing continues to this day as evident by the fact that ShutterBox only sold about a thousand or so copies at direct market comic shops. The rest of ShutterBox’s sales were all through the regular book market (book stores, Amazon, Suncoast Video, etc.). This difference between the direct market and the regular book market is also reflected in our signings. We don’t usually do signings at comic book shops because no one shows up for us, but we will do them at regular book stores because at places like Waldenbooks we draw a long line of fans. So, I'm rather thrilled about getting back to where we always intended to be: book stores.

If I can recommend anything at all, it would be to yes, network with other creators, but also try to go to conventions where publishers of comics are sure to appear (like San Diego Comic Con, APE, Anime Expo). Research via the Internet the publisher that you intend to approach and follow any guidelines posted at their website. Eventually, it may be a good idea to get an agent or a manager, but that's a whole different arena, and usually, in the case of comics, one that comes after you make a name for yourself.

Rivkah wrote:
Rikki: Eep! I meant Bookscan..


Ah, Bookscan. That one I do know about. The $9,000 price tag usually gets Tavisha and I to call it "book scam," but for a publisher I think it can be worth having the information. I wish they had a discount for authors, though.

-Rikki
_________________
http://www.tavicat.com/index.html
http://sadcircusbythesea.typepad.com/
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
IronMouse
Power Level: Jeice


Joined: 29 Mar 2004
Posts: 384
Location: Sydney

PostPosted: Tue Nov 02, 2004 12:29 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Thanks for the help, Rikki. Smile

I guess you're right - up until now, all your dealings have been with the closed direct market, so I guess you don't have all that much to offer with self-promotion when it comes to the relatively new "manga" market in America. It's baffling... I tell you. The article from the Comics Reporter describes it perfectly - it's NOT the 90s all over, this is something new and strange. Manga has gone mainstream (or almost mainstream), and that's what baffles the Comics Reporter. Obviously, alot more big companies such as Hyperion (Disney) are going to throw their weight into the Next Big Thing.

As for finding yourself a publisher, that's not really a problem (for me). I'm just wondering about this Brave New World, that's all, and what it means. Will promotions of oneself now be more like that of book authors rather than.... whatever it was before? It used to be the comic geeks and Star Trek fans, and the conventions reflected that. But now that manga is primarily sold in bookstores and PERCEIVED that way by the mainstream, it's suddenly gained a veneer of respectability.

That *respectability* part is important, because it will have some bearing on how one will market themselves. Before, just traipse up in your T-shirt and jeans, and talk the geeky talk with everyone. NOW, there's a bunch of corporate suits milling about, and it's all about marketing and selling yourself in a slick, multi-media sort of way. Maybe I'm exaggerating, but I'm genuinely wondering whether this is the direction the manga market will go in. Not a bad thing, ofcourse - I always wear suits anyway. Razz

---
http://www.queeniechan.com/
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
ElinWinkler
Power Level: Nappa


Joined: 19 May 2004
Posts: 23
Location: San Antonio, TX

PostPosted: Wed Nov 03, 2004 6:19 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Aimi wrote:
Yes, it's important that you go at things on your own initiative. ^^ i did that and got some of my work published by Radio Comix. ^^ But going back to what Rivkah said, i don't think anything will go anywhere without shmoozing... i mean, i've been pubslihed by Radio, but they won't help me with hyping my stuff like they do with their "friends," and if i try to nag them about it with PM and such, they don't really respond and tell me it's my fault for not advertizing the hell out of it. =P


I'm really sorry you somehow got that impression of us at Radio, Aimi. I'd also really like to know who exactly told you that it was your "own fault", since that's nothing I'd ever say to any artist, ever. Radio is a small company, it's true, with limited resources for advertising and marketing things. I'm also sorry you seem to think we only advertise or promote our "friends", which isn't the case at all (often, we don't really know the artists we are promoting that well, but they all need to be promoted because we're publishing them). We mostly try to concentrate our promotion on the books that need it the most desperately- which means yes, we have promoted Mangaphile as much as humanly possible in the past. (Sending out review copies to every magazine we could think of, sending out thousands of freebie promotional copies to anime conventions to give away to the fans there to try to get them hooked, advertising it on our site and in the trade magazines when the book started, etc. Sadly, despite all of these efforts, the book just didn't catch on.)

The PM system on our forum can be goofy at times, especially mine, since people seem to like to flood it with PMs. (They'll copy and paste the same PM to me dozens of times, which fills up the small PM space every user is allotted.) We're trying to keep all our PMs and emails and everything answered and keep over 250 different artists in a dozen different genres happy, but it's a difficult task and sometimes, some things do slip through the cracks. There's a lot to keep track of in trying to keep this crazy machine going, and there are only three of us trying to do the work of about eight. Again, I deeply apologize for the fact that you have somehow gotten the idea that we are purposely ignoring you and your work, but believe me, that was never my intention and I am actually quite saddened that you've gotten that impression.

--Elin at Radio
_________________
Job: http://www.radiocomix.com
Forum: http://patduke.com/forum
Life: http://www.livejournal.com/users/doronjosama
Ebay: http://members.ebay.com/aboutme/silverjain
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
IronMouse
Power Level: Jeice


Joined: 29 Mar 2004
Posts: 384
Location: Sydney

PostPosted: Wed Nov 03, 2004 7:17 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

To Elin: Have you tried gaining venture capitalist support? I ask because in this day and age, there's alot of buzz surrounding the booming manga industry in venture-capitalist land, and if you use it effectively Radio Comix may be able to get some financial backing on board.

Independent press comix can be cash-strapped, but hitching a "wave" when it comes can get you cash from people interested in a slice of the pie.

---
http://www.queeniechan.com/
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
ElinWinkler
Power Level: Nappa


Joined: 19 May 2004
Posts: 23
Location: San Antonio, TX

PostPosted: Wed Nov 03, 2004 10:13 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

IronMouse wrote:
To Elin: Have you tried gaining venture capitalist support? I ask because in this day and age, there's alot of buzz surrounding the booming manga industry in venture-capitalist land, and if you use it effectively Radio Comix may be able to get some financial backing on board.

Independent press comix can be cash-strapped, but hitching a "wave" when it comes can get you cash from people interested in a slice of the pie.


There are very few people interested in actually investing money in such things. Comics (and publishing in general) are traditionally thought of as a bad risk when it comes to loans and investors.

Also, Radio is a company that is 7 years old. We have a very niche market (furry comics, American manga, gay comics and adult comics), so while our sales are okay for us, they are only good because we have extremely low overhead. We've only just signed our bookstore distribution deal, so that's all still being worked out. Quite frankly, we do not look good on paper to investors, and on the other side of the coin, I don't want a lot of investors telling me how to run my business. Radio has never been about becoming fantastically wealthy or about cashing in on trends, it's always been about publishing comics we personally like from artists whose work we personally believe in. This has been our business plan from the very beginning in 1997. That plan may mean that we will never be rich, no matter how hard we work, but it does mean that every day I can look in the mirror and be proud of every single thing we've published. We've taken chances on a lot of artists who have gone on to become successes- people like Michael Vega, Diana Sprinkle and Richard Moore, to name a few. We're all about being a place for new talent to try their wings, which is not what investors want to hear. Investors want to hear about sure-fire successes, immediate and huge returns on their investments. Sadly, I can't lie to people in order to try to get their money out of them- it just reeks of dishonesty to me. I'd much rather deal plainly with things and make comics I believe in. And yeah, I guess that might make me a little weird, but I don't want to have to lose control of my company later. I've seen far too many companies fail due to investors pulling out at the last minute, or due to investors wanting the company to go in a different direction than intended. I watched that kind of thing almost tear Antarctic Press apart while I worked there- cashing in on the popular waves of the time got them some money and a couple of investors, but it was all short-term and ended up causing them deeper problems later. (Problems which led to my downsizing and eventual forming of Radio, in fact!)

And it'd be difficult to walk into some investor's office and say "good morning, we're from Radio Comix and we publish gay adult books, would you like to invest in our company?" ^_^; I don't think we'd get many takers!

--Elin
_________________
Job: http://www.radiocomix.com
Forum: http://patduke.com/forum
Life: http://www.livejournal.com/users/doronjosama
Ebay: http://members.ebay.com/aboutme/silverjain
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Aimi
Power Level: Recoome


Joined: 12 Oct 2004
Posts: 246

PostPosted: Thu Nov 04, 2004 8:18 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

>Elin-san

Thanks for your responce, and thank you for the apology.

i didn't mean to bash Radio... i was just frustrated. i post in the forum, i PM you, but i get no responce. That's fine; i understand you're busy and that you're understaffed. i waitress at a restaurant where there's only 4 of us stationed and we don't get sections so we're waiting on all 19 tables and 10 bar seats. But when one of your friends post, it's up in the "hype" section the very next day. (Ebin and May DVD, some short-story web comic, Eddie's portfolio, etc) i can't seem to get a responce unless i get cranky and complain; smiling and waiting doesn't get me anywhere.

i don't hang out in the Radio forums to advertise Radio stuff. i think that would be silly. Although, now i do have an advertisement in my sig. i do, however, advertise at cons. i bring all the trib copies i've recieved and have it at my artists' alley table so that people can come by and read through them (i guess i shouldn't sell my trib copies but instead direct them to RadioComix Store?), i have a "workes published" page on my website, and have put links back to Radio on that page. i go to another forum where i do have a little ad for Radio in my sig. i am trying to spread the word.

i don' t mean to dispute this over a public forum, i apologize. i just needed to explain myself.

Sorry to go off topic. ^^;
-Aimi
_________________
... there is no Angel...
http://www.arek-net.com/
Support Indie Manga! Radio Comix
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
ElinWinkler
Power Level: Nappa


Joined: 19 May 2004
Posts: 23
Location: San Antonio, TX

PostPosted: Thu Nov 04, 2004 9:47 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Aimi wrote:
>Elin-san

Thanks for your responce, and thank you for the apology.

i didn't mean to bash Radio... i was just frustrated. i post in the forum, i PM you, but i get no responce. That's fine; i understand you're busy and that you're understaffed. i waitress at a restaurant where there's only 4 of us stationed and we don't get sections so we're waiting on all 19 tables and 10 bar seats. But when one of your friends post, it's up in the "hype" section the very next day. (Ebin and May DVD, some short-story web comic, Eddie's portfolio, etc) i can't seem to get a responce unless i get cranky and complain; smiling and waiting doesn't get me anywhere.

i don't hang out in the Radio forums to advertise Radio stuff. i think that would be silly. Although, now i do have an advertisement in my sig. i do, however, advertise at cons. i bring all the trib copies i've recieved and have it at my artists' alley table so that people can come by and read through them (i guess i shouldn't sell my trib copies but instead direct them to RadioComix Store?), i have a "workes published" page on my website, and have put links back to Radio on that page. i go to another forum where i do have a little ad for Radio in my sig. i am trying to spread the word.

i don' t mean to dispute this over a public forum, i apologize. i just needed to explain myself.


Thanks for explaining yourself. It's funny that you consider Christina one of my friends, since until these last couple of years, I barely talked to her at cons- she just turned stuff in and we printed it. In fact, until Yaoi-con this last weekend, we'd never even hung out together at a convention! (At San Diego, she was at our booth, and I think Pat talked to her more than me!) The Ebin & May DVD got a big push because we ordered a ton of them to stock in the Radio store. I have to pay for those things, of course I'm going to write a press release for them to try to sell them! ^_^; Plenty of other things have not gotten press releases on the Forum- the Original Art section of the web catalog, the other portfolios we've added since Eddie's first ones (which includes Christina's folios...), etc. It's not about a personal slight against anyone or a personal bias towards anyone, the press releases on the forum are just all about trying to sell items we have in stock or to motivate our existing fanbase.

Also, which web-comic are you talking about? If it's something posted in the Marketplace & Hype section of the forum- anyone can post there (and they do, constantly!)! There's nothing stopping anyone from posting their advertisements, personal hype or plugs for their works in that section. (And it's a good idea for Radio artists to post there about all their new stuff- our readers rely on that section to lern about what Radio artists are up to!) Checking through the official press releases that I have written for the Radio Comix News section, I can't find any webcomic news. The last time I talked about a webcomic was when I promoted Baker By Night from WirePop, which was ages ago- and for the record, I have never even met Tracy in person. I do know Hanrahan, but since his last book at Radio didn't really perform well, I thought I'd mention his online comic, to show people he was still working, even if not with us. (I've never done any promo for his stories in the anthologies we publish... he's been in Furrlough countless times and written a bunch of articles for Mangaphile.) I've tried to promote BBN on my own time and own dime, completely seperate from Radio also. But that's because Hanrahan cannot work a regular job due to health reasons, so I wanted him to be able to get some money from his online comic. (Not that it helped, since the comic is dead anyway.) While we do try to help our friends, like any human on the planet, we're not like Marvel or DC where we only hand out the awesome assignments to people we like. Unlike other larger companies out there, we also don't just concentrate press releases/hype on our "big names" or biggest sellers- we are the complete opposite, in fact. If a book is weird or a hard sell, or doesn't really perform well, those are usually the books (and attached creators) we push the hardest! After all, you don't have to advertise the heck out of the book everyone is buying already, you have to let those people know the other, less "big" books exist. Everyone has the same chances at Radio and I try my hardest to be fair to people. But it's going to make it very difficult for me to write press releases for our books that need them if those releases are going to mean offending other artists who work for us.

Anyway, I am rambling too much about my personal comic publishing beliefs, so I'll stop now. I am still sad this situation had to happen, but at least we were able to get it discussed.

And kudos on the self-promotion you have already done for your work, Aimi. It really is an essential part of creating a name in comics, and I wish I had more time to devote to generating more hype for everyone I've printed.

--Elin
_________________
Job: http://www.radiocomix.com
Forum: http://patduke.com/forum
Life: http://www.livejournal.com/users/doronjosama
Ebay: http://members.ebay.com/aboutme/silverjain
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Lime
Power Level: Kui


Joined: 28 Oct 2004
Posts: 42
Location: New Jersey

PostPosted: Thu Nov 04, 2004 4:01 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
We have a very niche market (furry comics, American manga, gay comics and adult comics), so while our sales are okay for us, they are only good because we have extremely low overhead. We've only just signed our bookstore distribution deal, so that's all still being worked out.


Elin,

You brought up a few interesting thing in you recent post. I want to quickly throw this out there while still hot (I know, doesn't really have anything to do with the topic of this thread but since we have all these people assebled her may as well discuss it).

So, you're able to cut some corners with low overhead and help from Brenner but looking at the business model of the pamphlet industry you rightfully admit that there isn't enough margin to satisfy any substantial investment.

Although I have respect for the level of integrity that you bring to the table I would find it extremly difficult to operate with no light at the end of the tunnel. Now, I've published some books myself in 2001 (actually Elin, do you remember in San Diego 2001 you got our Tusk Tour Book (Wallas cover) with a sketch from Mary Hildebrandt and we chatted briefly) but decided to pull the plug after seeing the direction and some serious financial house-cleaning. We could have supported ourselves but only barely and there was no sign to believe that it was going to get any better.

I'm not a super-proponent of venture funding but without colatoral you'll never get a bank loan. Most creative businesses are venture funded (i.e. Tokyopop, as you can see on ther website is owned by several Japanese investment banks). So I think if you get lucky and find an angel you could be better off. I believe that in order to make money you have to spend some money. Very few businesses, ideas or properties actually make it with nothing.

Anyway, my question is, do you ever think about where you're going to be in five/ten years and with the pamphlet industry in the shape it is right now and no reason to believe that it is going to grow? And by the numbers that Rikki mentioned above, wouldn't it be more desireable to drop all the comics and focus on putting our paperbacks (which of course would take some kind of an investment since the money turn-around is much slower than the direct-market)?

Sorry for all the digging and drilling and I'm really sad that there was no support for Mangaphile, I used to pick it up whenever I saw an issue.

Take care,

David
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
ElinWinkler
Power Level: Nappa


Joined: 19 May 2004
Posts: 23
Location: San Antonio, TX

PostPosted: Thu Nov 04, 2004 7:06 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

David:

Actually, we are cancelling all plans for the traditional comic mini/ limited/ongoing series, in favor of moving towards original graphic novels, along the lines of what Oni Press is doing. (I've talked about this extensively on my Livejournal over the past few months...) We are keeping our other core anthology titles, as they are still decent money-makers and turn a profit, but we are really pushing the people who get published in them to consider the longer term and to have an eye for eventual graphic novel collection for those stories once there is enough material. Besides which, the Japanese model of the anthology that later generates graphic novel material is one that is very dear to my heart, and is always something we wanted to emulate. But, due to the fact that we often take chances on new, completely untried creators in the anthologies, it can be a gamble on what will continue and what won't. ^_^; However, I still believe there should be a company out there that offers a place for those people to test their wings and get a taste of what being published is like- and I hope Radio can always be a place like that.

Ideally, we are hoping to have a steady mix of original graphic novels, collections of stories that have run in our anthologies (and on the Mangaphile: Online site that is in the planning stages), with our three core anthologies mixed in. Some of our other anthologies are being retooled in a new perfect-bound format, and some are only annuals, so they aren't really impacted by the slow death of the pamphlet. This is something we've already been making plans for, but as it wasn't completely germane to the conversation at hand, I saw no reason to bring it up. ^_^;

In five to ten years, I hope to have a strong back catalog of graphic novels in all the genres we are already publishing, and hopefully, our regular anthologies will still be going as well. Furrlough has already managed to last 13 years, through the Distributor Wars of the 1990's and other things that killed bigger companies than us. We've lasted 7 years already, without compromising our principles or having to take orders from anyone else. And, we have invested outside funds into Radio at many opportunities- my partner Pat regularly does coloring work for the majors, which he rolls back into Radio, I do outside work as well. In the past, we've done freelance work for Studio Proteus also. (Currently, Pat is working on the animated film A Scanner Darkly, again so Radio can benefit. ^_^) We're just really dedicated to pursuing our own vision and we'll make sacrifices to do that if we have to. By low overhead, it means we have a tiny staff (three full time people, two part timers), we don't have big, fancy offices (zoning is quite lax here in Texas when it comes to home offices), and we don't spend money like crazy on wacky advertising schemes. (I've seen that destroy many a startup comic publisher!) Our biggest bills are printing (and we don't get "help from Brenner"- we're charged the same amount as anyone else, and we pay them just like anyone else does...), taxes (which no one can really do anything about), shipping and postage costs and artist royalties. Everything else is minimal, and kept on a tight budget. ^_^ I was partly raised by my Depression-era grandma, who helped run her husband's businesses, so I guess the entrepeneurial spirit is in my blood!

And really, what it all comes down to is having books that pay for their printing, and which pay the artists something for their hard work and vision. If I can manage that, I consider Radio a success. Again, maybe that's weird of me, but this is what I do because I love it. I am extremely passionate about comics, and that drives me to work 16 hour days six days a week. ^_^ While huge amounts of money would be nice, I judge success more by going to a convention and talking to fans who are really passionate about the books we've made. That is worth more to me than money, even if it brands me as a crazy person to think that. ^_^; I just want to publish comics I believe in, and have our stories inspire a connection or emotional reaction from the readers. That's better than any truckload of money backed up to my door by some huge faceless corporation any day of the week. ^_^

Anyway, rambling again. Geez, sorry. ^_^; I said I was passionate about my company. Maybe a little too much!

--Elin
_________________
Job: http://www.radiocomix.com
Forum: http://patduke.com/forum
Life: http://www.livejournal.com/users/doronjosama
Ebay: http://members.ebay.com/aboutme/silverjain
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
IronMouse
Power Level: Jeice


Joined: 29 Mar 2004
Posts: 384
Location: Sydney

PostPosted: Fri Nov 05, 2004 12:51 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

ElinWinkler wrote:

Actually, we are cancelling all plans for the traditional comic mini/ limited/ongoing series, in favor of moving towards original graphic novels, along the lines of what Oni Press is doing.


Ya know, you've got real difficult act to balance. If that's what you're going to do, you probably WILL have to attract venture capital, but that's also usually where all the trouble starts because venture capitalists tend to want to see returns pretty quickly.

Anyway, regardless of what your situation is, I hope you do succeed Smile, and that something that could shake the current American manga industry won't happen. The more original voices there are out there, the better.

---
http://www.queeniechan.com/
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
ElinWinkler
Power Level: Nappa


Joined: 19 May 2004
Posts: 23
Location: San Antonio, TX

PostPosted: Fri Nov 05, 2004 9:02 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

IronMouse wrote:

Ya know, you've got real difficult act to balance. If that's what you're going to do, you probably WILL have to attract venture capital, but that's also usually where all the trouble starts because venture capitalists tend to want to see returns pretty quickly.


Actually, no, we won't. We're not planning to go bananas and publish a half dozen graphic novels every month or anything. ^_^ We're starting small, doing one every so often. It takes us a while to get the production done on graphic novels anyway, so there'd be no way we could start doing them as though they were regular comic book issues. All our previous graphic novels have paid for themselves, so I am pretty certain the new ones will as well- and besides, now they have the option of being in bookstores and on Amazon, which is a whole new market for us. The worst thing it will mean for us is a shift in our release schedule, and a longer wait for artists to see their work in print. (Since they will have to finish a graphic novel worth of work before it gets printed now...)

There are other small companies using the graphic novel model- Alternative Press, Studio Ironcat, Antarctic Press, etc. If those guys are using venture capital, they're hiding it pretty well (esp. the first two, who have had financial difficulties recently...). The comic industry in America is *small*, even with the new explosion into bookstores. It is still entirely possible to run a successful company without having to kowtow to a bunch of investors with no creative vision. That may become a thing of the past someday, but it's in no danger of happening yet.

Quote:
Anyway, regardless of what your situation is, I hope you do succeed Smile, and that something that could shake the current American manga industry won't happen. The more original voices there are out there, the better.


I hope nothing shakes things up either! We're still in a time of flux, and everyone is running to jump on the manga bandwagon. That just reminds me of the Black & White Bust of the 1980's, the Bad Girl Bust of the late 1990's and the Speculator Bust of the early 1990's. Whenever there's a bandwagon and a huge explosion of material to cash in on it, there's always an inevitable bust. It's just the way the industry works- it's self-correcting in a way. The big money never lasts forever. Thanks for the wishes for success, also! I have only positive thoughts for the future these days, so I hope it all works out. ^_^

--Elin
_________________
Job: http://www.radiocomix.com
Forum: http://patduke.com/forum
Life: http://www.livejournal.com/users/doronjosama
Ebay: http://members.ebay.com/aboutme/silverjain
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Lime
Power Level: Kui


Joined: 28 Oct 2004
Posts: 42
Location: New Jersey

PostPosted: Fri Nov 05, 2004 12:22 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
If that's what you're going to do, you probably WILL have to attract venture capital, but that's also usually where all the trouble starts because venture capitalists tend to want to see returns pretty quickly.


Iron Mouse: I'm with you on that. I've had two underfunded business now and I'm tired of it. Running out of money is one of the most typical business mistake (sigh!!). There are many forms of venture capital and not all them are evil. Don't forget, without it Tokyopop would not be here today.

Quote:
Actually, we are cancelling all plans for the traditional comic mini/ limited/ongoing series, in favor of moving towards original graphic novels, along the lines of what Oni Press is doing. (I've talked about this extensively on my Livejournal over the past few months...)


Elin: Sorry, I didn't read your lifejounal but that answers of course my question. It seems you guys have found a formula that works which is great. I'm certainly the first to admit that if it ain't broke don't fix it. I also think with your mix of niche titles and off-beat material you may score a hit sooner or later. I mean who would have thought a few years back that not just one, but two shonen-ai titles would crack the Bookscan top ten. So, who knows what's gonna be big tomorrow...

Also, just quickly something about Anthologies: I agree with you that they're fun to work on and to read. Only problem is that they're notoriously bad sellers (at least in the direct market). I don't think the Japanes model is ever gonna prevail here in the US because of significant cultural differences (like less public transportation commuters etc.). But what about something in the format of the RSOM books? Basically, standart manga size but with twenty to forty page installments on a monthly base for a specific topic (like you already have)?

David
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Pseudomé Studio Projects Forum Index -> TOKYOPOP And The Manga Industry All times are GMT - 5 Hours
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3
Page 3 of 3

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group